In modern skin care, sunscreen products have become an essential component. Prolonged exposure to ultraviolet (UV) radiation not only accelerates skin aging but also increases the risk of skin cancer. Therefore, protecting the skin from UV damage has become a crucial step in daily skin care routines. As awareness of the harmful effects of photoaging grows, the demand for effective sunscreen products is surging. Consumers are increasingly seeking sunscreens that offer broad-spectrum protection (against UVA and UVB rays) while also providing additional skin care benefits. To meet this growing demand, the formulation design of sunscreen products must focus not only on selecting the right UV filters but also on ensuring the product’s texture, stability, and the synergistic effects of other skin care ingredients. Understanding the effective ingredients and formulation design is key to developing sunscreens that deliver both protection and comfort!
Main types of sunscreen products
1. Physical Sunscreen
Ingredients: Common physical sunscreen agents include zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.
Mechanism: Physical sunscreens work by forming a protective layer on the skin’s surface that reflects or scatters UV rays, preventing them from penetrating the skin. This form of sun protection acts like a shield or armor for the skin, offering immediate protection upon application. These sunscreens are generally considered gentle and are suitable for sensitive skin or children.
Advantages:
Provides immediate protection without the need to wait.
Typically gentle, making it ideal for sensitive skin.
Offers broad-spectrum protection, especially effective against UVA rays.
Disadvantages:
Tends to leave a white cast or heavy residue on the skin, particularly in products with higher concentrations of zinc oxide.
Can have a thicker texture, which may feel heavy or clog pores.
2. Chemical Sunscreen
Ingredients: Common chemical sunscreen agents include avobenzone, octocrylene, octinoxate, and oxybenzone.
Mechanism: Chemical sunscreens work by absorbing UV radiation and converting it into heat, which is then released from the skin. This type of sunscreen needs to form an even layer on the skin to absorb specific wavelengths of UV rays, providing effective protection.
Advantages:
Usually has a lighter texture, making it easier to apply and spread, suitable for daily use.
Doesn’t leave a visible white residue, making it more suitable for darker skin tones.
Works well with other skin care products.
Disadvantages:
Requires about 15-20 minutes after application to become effective.
Some chemical ingredients may irritate sensitive skin or trigger allergic reactions.
Chemical filters can break down over time, requiring frequent reapplication.
3. Hybrid Sunscreen
In recent years, hybrid sunscreens have emerged, combining both physical and chemical sunscreen ingredients. These products provide a dual-action defense by reflecting and absorbing UV rays, offering comprehensive protection.
The effective ingredients in sunscreen products
1. Physical Sunscreen Agents
Physical sunscreen agents work by reflecting and scattering UV rays, forming a protective layer on the skin. The two primary ingredients are:
Zinc Oxide
Protection Range: Broad-spectrum protection against both UVA and UVB rays
Features: Zinc oxide is one of the most effective broad-spectrum sunscreen ingredients. It offers strong protection against both UVA and UVB rays, making it ideal for sensitive skin. It is also highly stable, meaning it does not easily degrade when exposed to sunlight. This makes it a common choice for baby and sensitive skin formulations.
Drawbacks: It may leave a white cast on the skin, especially at higher concentrations, making it less aesthetically pleasing for some users.
Titanium Dioxide
Protection Range: Effective against UVB and some UVA rays
Features: Titanium dioxide is particularly effective at blocking UVB rays and is more transparent on the skin than zinc oxide. Its lightweight texture makes it suitable for daily use without leaving a heavy or greasy feeling.
Drawbacks: It provides weaker protection against UVA1 (long-wave UVA) rays, so it is often combined with other ingredients for full-spectrum protection.
2. Chemical Sunscreen Agents
Chemical sunscreen agents work by absorbing UV radiation and converting it into heat, which is then released from the skin. Common chemical filters include:
Avobenzone
Protection Range: Broad-spectrum protection, especially against UVA rays
Features: Avobenzone is one of the few chemical ingredients that provides effective long-wave UVA protection. It is often used in combination with other filters to ensure overall stability.
Drawbacks: It degrades quickly when exposed to sunlight, so it needs to be paired with stabilizers like octocrylene to maintain its effectiveness.
Octocrylene
Protection Range: UVB and some UVA protection
Features: Octocrylene provides UV protection while also enhancing the stability of other ingredients like avobenzone. It is highly water-resistant, making it a common ingredient in water-resistant sunscreens.
Drawbacks: It can sometimes cause irritation or allergic reactions in sensitive skin.
Octinoxate
Protection Range: Primarily UVB
Features: Octinoxate is an effective UVB absorber, commonly used in daily sunscreen products. It has a lightweight, easily spreadable texture.
Drawbacks: It does not provide UVA protection and is photounstable, breaking down when exposed to sunlight unless stabilized.
Oxybenzone
Protection Range: Broad-spectrum protection against both UVA and UVB
Features: Oxybenzone is a strong, broad-spectrum UV filter that protects against both UVA and UVB rays. It is often used in high-performance sunscreens.
Drawbacks: It may cause skin irritation and is associated with environmental concerns, leading to its restriction in some countries.
Tinosorb S and Tinosorb M
Protection Range: Broad-spectrum protection against UVA and UVB rays
Features: These newer-generation chemical filters offer high photostability and broad-spectrum protection. They are low-irritation and suitable for most skin types. Tinosorb M can also scatter UV rays, acting as a hybrid filter.
Drawbacks: Tinosorb ingredients can be more expensive and are not yet approved in all countries.
3. Hybrid Sunscreen Ingredients
To create more effective sunscreens, many products use hybrid formulas, combining physical and chemical filters. This allows them to offer broader-spectrum protection and improve the product’s texture and stability.
Key factors to consider when designing sunscreen formulations
1. Ingredient Selection
Effective Sunscreen Agents: Choose suitable physical and chemical filters to ensure broad-spectrum protection. The formulation should include ingredients effective against both UVA and UVB rays, such as zinc oxide, titanium dioxide, and avobenzone.
Supporting Ingredients: Incorporate antioxidants (like Vitamin E and green tea extract) to enhance skin protection, or add moisturizing agents (like glycerin and hyaluronic acid) to improve the product’s hydration properties.
2. Photostability
Ingredient Stability: Some chemical sunscreens degrade easily under light exposure, so incorporating stabilizers (like octocrylene or benzophenones) is necessary to enhance the formulation’s stability and ensure long-lasting effectiveness in sunlight.
pH Adjustment: Maintain an appropriate pH level to ensure the stability of sunscreen agents and compatibility with the skin.
3. Sensory Feel and Texture
Formulation Texture: Design various textures based on the target user demographic, such as lotions, gels, creams, or sprays, to ensure easy application and absorption.
Skin Feel: Avoid greasy or sticky products that can detract from user experience. Lightweight, oil-free formulations are often preferred.
4. Skin Compatibility
Sensitivity Testing: Choose gentle and non-irritating ingredients, especially for sunscreens targeting sensitive skin or babies.
Allergen Avoidance: Avoid known allergens to ensure the product’s safety and broad applicability.
5. Water Resistance
Water-Resistant Formulation: If the product claims to be water-resistant, include suitable ingredients (such as silicones) to maintain protection during sweating or water exposure.
6. Regulatory Compliance
Regulatory Adherence: Ensure the formulation complies with the regulatory requirements of the target market, including ingredient restrictions and labeling requirements.
Clinical Testing: Conduct necessary clinical trials to verify sun protection efficacy and skin safety, ensuring the product’s compliance in the marketplace.
Sunscreen formulations for different skin types
1. Oily Skin
Characteristics: Oily skin tends to produce excess sebum, has enlarged pores, and is prone to acne.
Formulation Suggestions:
Lightweight Texture: Choose gel, lotion, or water-based sunscreens that absorb easily and are non-greasy.
Oil-Free Formulas: Opt for “oil-free” or “non-comedogenic” products to avoid clogging pores.
Oil-Control Ingredients: Incorporate oil-controlling agents like salicylic acid or tea tree oil to reduce shine and prevent breakouts.
2. Dry Skin
Characteristics: Dry skin often feels tight, may crack, and lacks moisture.
Formulation Suggestions:
Moisturizing Ingredients: Select sunscreens containing hydrating ingredients (like glycerin, hyaluronic acid, or plant oils) for added moisture.
Rich Texture: Choose creams or oil-based sunscreens for better hydration.
Repairing Ingredients: Add repairing ingredients (like squalane or ceramides) to improve the skin barrier.
3. Sensitive Skin
Characteristics: Sensitive skin is prone to irritation, redness, or allergic reactions.
Formulation Suggestions:
Gentle Ingredients: Opt for fragrance-free and alcohol-free sunscreens that avoid irritating components.
Physical Sunscreens: Prioritize physical sunscreen agents (like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide), which are generally more suitable for sensitive skin.
Soothing Ingredients: Include soothing agents (like aloe vera, licorice root extract, or oatmeal extract) to reduce irritation and redness.
4. Combination Skin
Characteristics: Combination skin typically has an oily T-zone (forehead, nose, chin) while the cheeks may be dry.
Formulation Suggestions:
Balanced Formulation: Choose neutral formulas that work well for all areas of the face without being overly oily or drying.
Lightweight Lotion: Use lightweight lotion textures suitable for both the face and neck.
Balancing Ingredients: Add balancing ingredients (like oats or licorice extract) to regulate moisture levels in different areas.
5. Mature Skin
Characteristics: Mature skin may show fine lines, wrinkles, and sagging.
Formulation Suggestions:
Anti-Aging Ingredients: Select sunscreens containing anti-aging components (like retinol or peptides) to help improve skin elasticity.
Hydrating Ingredients: Include moisturizing ingredients (like collagen or hyaluronic acid) to enhance hydration and firmness.
High SPF: Consider sunscreens with higher SPF values for better protection.
Testing and validation of sunscreen products
1. Sunscreen Efficacy Testing
SPF Testing: Clinical trials are conducted to determine the SPF (Sun Protection Factor) value of sunscreen products. The test typically involves applying a specific amount of the sunscreen on the skin of volunteers and exposing it to a defined intensity of UVB radiation to evaluate its protective effect.
UVA Protection Testing: This assesses the product’s ability to protect against UVA radiation, commonly using PA (Protection Grade of UVA) ratings. This testing can involve human skin or other models to determine the sunscreen’s effectiveness.
2. Stability Testing
Photostability Testing: This tests the stability of sunscreen products under sunlight exposure. It involves evaluating the degradation of sunscreen ingredients under various light conditions (e.g., UV lamp exposure) to ensure long-lasting effectiveness in sunlight.
Thermal Stability Testing: Products are exposed to different temperature conditions to observe any changes or degradation in ingredients, ensuring safety and efficacy in high-temperature environments.
3. Skin Compatibility Testing
Irritation Testing: This evaluates the potential irritancy of the sunscreen on the skin, including allergic reactions and irritation. Patch testing is commonly used to assess the product’s safety on a small skin area.
Sensitivity Testing: Specific tests for sensitive skin are conducted to ensure the product does not cause discomfort or allergic reactions during use.
4. Sensory and Absorption Testing
Sensory Evaluation: User feedback and clinical tests assess the sunscreen’s sensory attributes, such as comfort, greasiness, and absorption speed after application.
Skin Absorption Testing: This evaluates how well the product absorbs into the skin, ensuring that the active ingredients can effectively penetrate and work on the skin.
5. Other Performance Testing
Water Resistance Testing: For products claiming to be water-resistant, evaluations are conducted to assess their protective effects after exposure to water, simulating activities like swimming or sweating.
Longevity Testing: This assesses how long the sunscreen maintains its protective effects on the skin, ensuring effective protection during daily activities (like swimming or sweating).
In conclusion, effective sunscreen products rely not only on their SPF value but also on the scientific selection of ingredients and thoughtful formulation design. Understanding the roles of active ingredients and the key elements of formulation can help consumers choose products best suited to their skin needs. Proper use of sunscreen in daily skin care is crucial for effectively protecting the skin from UV damage and delaying the signs of aging. Looking ahead, we hope that sunscreen products will continue to advance in technological innovation, ingredient safety, and user experience. As awareness of skin care grows, personalized and multifunctional sunscreens are expected to become the norm, helping consumers meet their diverse skin care needs while providing robust protection!
If you have any needs related to skin care projects or would like to learn more, feel free to contact us! Please remember to follow, share, and like our article, so that more people can benefit from this skin care knowledge!
